Back when I was a child (and I’m not telling you how long ago that was, only that I was born and raised in Putney), you kept your shoes on when you came inside a house, any house, unless you’d trodden in dog poop or if you’d been wearing grubby wellies or if your shoes had somehow got muddy (school cross-country races spring to mind). You kept your shoes off the furniture and the beds but running over the carpet in shoes was perfectly OK.

Gradually, it’s become more acceptable to take your shoes off at the door, and not just at your own house, either, but at other people’s houses as well. The only place it’s more or less a given that you won’t take your shoes off when you come in is at work. This is true even for cultures where taking shoes off at the door is the norm, such as Japan: shoes stay on at work because it’s work, not home.
For me, it was a slow transition from that Putney child who put shoes on first thing in the morning and kept them on until heading to the shower before bed to someone who has got whipping shoes off at the door down to fine art and is comfortable asking my host “And what do you want me to do with my shoes?” after the initial greetings and before I get in the door. The combination of rental properties with light-coloured carpets and children who loved sports and the outdoors probably had something to do with it, to say nothing of becoming more experienced in domestic carpet cleaning Putney.
Although quite a few people are OK with taking shoes off at the door of someone else’s house, others are still a bit iffy about the idea and think that’s far too casual and maybe a bit icky. Leaving aside the whole issue of cultures and traditions where removing shoes at the door is the norm, what is the best thing to do from a carpet cleaner’s perspective?
The Case For Removing Shoes At The Door
The main reason why people take shoes off at the door is that this keeps the carpets clean. There’s no doubt about this one. Shoes that have gone anywhere outside, even if you haven’t trodden in anything obviously grotty, will still bring in mud, grit and grime from the inside. I’ve just taken a look at the bottoms of my outdoor shoes (more on that below), and I can see bits of gravel stuck in the tread, scraps of grass, a few spots of mud and… is that bird poop? If I’d worn those shoes indoors, all that gravel, grass, mud and bird poop would have worked itself all over the carpets. And that’s with a pair of dry shoes. On a rainy day (in Putney SW15, it feels like it rains almost every day), water would have come in on the soles of my shoes as well.
You may wonder what the big deal is. After all, don’t we have vacuum cleaners to remove dirt from carpets? We do indeed, and vacuuming is certainly a good way to remove a lot of dirt, including the bits of grass and the more visible bits of gravel. However, there’s always some dirt that gets right down deep into the carpets and escapes the pull of the vacuum cleaners. Vacuums can’t remove mud or moisture, or other damp substances that can go from shoes to the carpet.
Honestly, you save yourself a world of dirt in your carpets by taking shoes off at the door. This means that your carpets look better for longer – and they last longer as well, as there will be less grit rubbing away at the bottom of the fibres with every step you take. Your carpets will probably smell fresher for longer as well.
Why People Keep Their Shoes On
As a professional carpet cleaner in Putney, taking shoes off at the door to keep the carpets clean is a bit of a no-brainer. However, I’ve heard a number of arguments for keeping shoes on at the door, some of which have at least something to do with preserving carpets. Here are some of the reasons I’ve heard, along with some possible counter-arguments or solutions to the problems raised.
- My shoes are clean. Um, no, they’re not. Take a damp paper towel and wipe that along the sole of your “clean” shoes, and you’ll see how much dirt there is down there.
- I don’t want to wave my smelly socks around someone else’s house. You wouldn’t wear a dirty work shirt when going to visit someone, would you? You’d change it. It’s not very hard to change your socks before heading out for dinner, so what is revealed when your shoes come off at the door is presentable, not smelly and free from holes.
- Bare feet are icky – think of all those sweaty feet going on the carpets. Granted, sweaty feet will put sweat on the carpets. However, not all feet are sweaty, especially if you’ve had a shower and put on clean socks before visiting, if you’ve been wearing well-ventilated shoes or if it’s a chilly day or any combination of the above. The amount of sweat that would get on carpet fibres is minimal compared with what comes off shoes. Of course, you need to keep your feet neat, which you should be doing anyway for health reasons. Why not take pride in your pinkies with a pedicure and a toe ring or so? At least cut your nails.
- Socks are OK on the carpet, but they’re really slippery on wooden floors and lino. This is a legitimate concern. If you don’t want to go completely barefoot, another option is to take slippers or a designated pair of indoor shoes with you, and instead of wearing bare feet or socks inside, slip on the slippers or indoor shoes (which really are cleaner than outdoor shoes, remember – Putney-rain, lol) when you come inside.
- If I take off my shoes, I’ll ruin my pantyhose. That’s certainly a problem. Your options here are either to go without pantyhose or just come prepared to get your feet naked. However, as the sort of outfit that requires nice stockings or pantyhose also tends to suit fancy footwear, keep reading.
- I’ve splashed out on some great fancy shoes and want to show them off! If you’ve seen those people who run or walk to work wearing trainers and then change into pumps at the door of the office, you know what to do. Have one pair of shoes for the journey if it involves walking, then change into your best Manolo Blahniks when you get there. If you only have a short trip from the car to the doorway, and if there are no red carpets or gallant knights spreading cloaks before your feet handy, then a quick wipe of your fancy shoes on the doormat should be adequate, as they’re unlikely to have picked up much muck between the car and the door.
- What are doormats for? Doormats are your extra line of defence to catch any dirt from fancy shoes or the times when someone has “just nipped out a little bit” in their indoor shoes. Doormats also catch wet feet brought in by dogs and children who’ve run outside barefoot. They also trap dust and other grub that might otherwise blow in through the door.
- It’s so lower class! This one, I don’t get this one. Does not taking your shoes off at the door imply that you need to do so because you’re a grubby peasant who works in the dirt? (As if posh polo players don’t get horse poop on their boots sometimes.) Does it imply that your host can’t afford to clean the carpet? Vacuum cleaners and hiring professional carpet cleaners aren’t that expensive! Or is this just some arbitrary thing like what you do with your little finger while drinking tea?
So, whether you are a shoes-on or shoes-off person, there are pros and against in each case. Your home is your castle, and it is you who decides what goes in your castle. From a professional carpet cleaner’s perspective, I can be both. It’s easy to clean a not-so-dirty carpet. At the same time, I love it when I compare the before and after photos of a really dirty carpet from a Putney house job. It just makes my day.